Monday—Wednesday & Friday 10a—5:30p, Thursday 10a—7p, Saturday 10a—5p 812.945.5959

Store Hours

Koerber's Offers Jewelry Appraisals

Jewelry appraisal

We perform appraisals for insurance and routinely work closely with insurance companies to ensure accurate coverage for your most precious jewelry items.  By having a thorough appraisal performed and then insured, you can rest peacefully knowing that your jewelry is covered in case of theft, loss, or disaster.

What is an appraisal?

Quite simply, and appraisal is a thorough and informed evaluation of the style, contents, and condition of a jewelry item.  Although appraisals are commonly used for everything from reselling an item to settling an estate, our appraisals are designed to clearly represent your item when said item is no longer present to be inspected and can be effectively used for insurance replacement.

How much time do I need to allow for an appraisal to be performed?

Two weeks. 

Our appraisals are detailed and thorough, meaning that we like to inspect your item from all angles, take multiple measurements, and quality of all metals and stones.  A rushed appraisal usually means a lackluster evaluation.

Will I need to leave my item?

Yes! Our excellent staff will inspect the basic condition of your item during your visit, and you will receive a receipt listing this information-- as well as a picture of your jewelry.  This receipt will also document the expected date of completion.  All jewelry items are safely kept in our vaults while in our possession. 

What other information do I need to know before appraising?

All jewelry items will be cleaned, free of charge, during their time with us.  We will also inform you of any damage and potential repairs.  If your appraisal is ready before the quoted two weeks, we will call you immediately.

How much does an appraisal cost?

Our pricing is as follows:

$125 (plus applicable sales tax) for one item.

Should you have multiple items for appraisals, we give you a bit of a price break!  For every item brought in at the same time, a $75 per item fee applies. (Example: I have five items to appraise.  My first item will then be $125, and the other four items will be $75 each.  The total would be $425 and tax).

Upon purchasing an item here at Koerber’s you will receive a free complimentary appraisal with your purchase. 

I need my item appraised faster than two weeks!

An additional fee per item applies.

Additional disclosures:

We reserve the right to amend our fees at any time, which includes an upcharge for items deemed more intricate than normally encountered.  Our staff will inform you of such upcharges before any appraisals are performed.

Your Appraiser:

Sarah E. Martin joined the staff of Koerber’s Fine Jewelry in 2013, serving as a Diamond Specialist and Staff Appraiser.  Ms. Martin holds the prestigious diploma of Graduate Gemologist from the Gemological Institute of America (GIA, 2016), as well as certificates in Diamond Grading, Colored Stones, and Gemstone Identification.  She is also an Accredited Jewelry Professional (GIA).  In addition to extensive diamond knowledge, Ms. Martin facilitates custom jewelry design, heirloom jewelry restyling, colored stone sourcing, and specially requested rare diamonds. 

Ms. Martin also holds degrees in classical music from Furman University in Greenville, SC (Bachelor of Arts) and Indiana University’s Jacobs School of Music (Master of Music, Performer Diploma).


We provide 100% "Peace of Mind" with every purchase. Learn more.

Located in New Albany, Indiana, Koerber’s is a family-owned and operated fine jewelry store. Over thirty years ago, we set out to sell the highest quality diamonds and jewelry at competitive prices. From designer engagement rings to fashion jewelry, we offer the highest quality merchandise backed with exceptional customer service.

Conveniently located on Blackiston Mill Road, our newly-renovated and expanded space is waiting, with a great selection of fine jewelry from your favorite designers. While our staff is waiting to help you find the perfect piece, we invite you to look through our online jewelry store catalog and bookmark the styles you like best.


Finanace your next jewelry purchase at Koerber's, Southern Indiana's premier family-owned jewelry store.

Finance the jewlery of your dreams with a wide range of interest-free financing plans. Applying in store takes only a few moments and all you need to bring is your driver's license. Financing is available for any of our products or services, just contact us or visit our beautiful showroom to learn more. Learn more now.