Skip to primary navigationSkip to main contentSkip to footer
HOURS: Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Friday 10a-5:30p; Thursday 10a-7p and Saturday 10a-5p
  • 812.945.5959
  • VISIT US
  • Toggle Search Menu
  • Toggle My Account Menu
  • Toggle My Wishlist
  • Toggle Shopping Cart Menu
Koerbers Fine Jewelry Inc logo
  • Engagement
    Choose your Style
    Solitaire Side-Stone Three Stone Halo Pave Antique Single Row Multi Row Bypass
    Solitaire Side-Stone Three Stone Halo Pave
    Vintage Single Row Multi Row Bypass
    Engagement Rings
    Anniversary Rings
    Wedding Bands
    Men’s Wedding BandsLadies Wedding Bands
    Everything in Love
    Everything in Love

    Explore All Engagement
  • Diamonds
    Search for Diamonds
    Search for Diamonds
    Learn About Diamonds
    Diamond Buying TipsThe Four Cs of DiamondsFind Your BirthstoneOur Diamonds
    Diamond Jewelry
    Diamond Fashion RingsDiamond BraceletsDiamond NecklacesDiamond Earrings
    Gemstones
    Gemstone Jewelry

    Explore All Diamonds
  • Jewelry
    Engagement Rings
    Wedding Bands
    Fashion Rings
    Bracelets
    Earrings
    Necklaces & Pendants
    Watches
    Estate Jewelry
    Men's Jewelry
    Birthstones
    Gifts
    Miscellaneous
    Permanent Jewelry Charms

    Explore All Jewelry
  • Designers
    BenchmarkChristopher DesignsDoves JewelryErinessG-ShockGabriel & Co
    Hearts On FireKendra ScottKoerber's CollectionLe VianMark HenryMemoire
    Monica Rich KosannPandoraSeikoShinolaShy CreationSimon G
    Sloane StreetUneekVahanZeghani

    Designers
  • Services
    Diamond & Gold Buying
    Diamond & Gold Buying
    Financing
    Financing
    Custom Jewelry Design
    Custom Jewelry Design
    Repairs & Appraisals
    Repairs & Appraisals

    Explore All Services
  • About Us
    Our Store
    Our Store
    Upcoming Events
    Upcoming Events
    Testimonials
    Testimonials
    Get In Touch
    Get In Touch

    Explore All About Us
  • Sale
  1. Home
  2. Custom Engagement Rings | New Albany, IN | Koerber's Fine Jewelry

Custom Engagement Rings in the New Albany, IN Area



Build Something Beautiful

At the start of your new life as a couple, building a custom engagement ring demonstrates your commitment to build something new together. Just as you construct your ring and select the elements you most desire, from the diamond to the metal to the setting, you create a foundation to explore, try something new, and start an adventure side by side with your partner's love and support. A custom ring is a symbolic testament to those sentiments that will endure forever. Whether you or your spouse-to-be chooses the design for a custom engagement ring or you embark on the journey together, you're sure to have built something special at the end of the day.

Exactly What You Want

If you or your partner has had a dream ring in mind for years, a custom engagement ring is the perfect way to get exactly what you want in a ring without having to compromise on any design aspects based on the available selection at your local jeweler. Combine elements of several designs you like and nix or alter parts you don't; when you build a custom ring, you get to choose every component, from the diamond to the number of stones, from the setting to the size. When building a custom ring at Koerber's Fine Jewelry, your local jewelry store in the New Albany area, you will always have seasoned professionals and master jewelers guiding you with consultations and design sessions to ensure that your every need is met when designing your perfect, unique engagement ring.

A Cut Above

The shape of a diamond is a key contributor to the overall design and aesthetic of your custom engagement ring. More traditional shapes include round brilliant cuts and ovals. Marquise, pear, and heart-shaped diamonds are less common but equally gorgeous when seated in a halo setting or set as the focal point in a solitaire-style ring. Older and more vintage, old miner's cut and rose cut diamonds have fallen out of modern graces but are an excellent choice for those who prefer a more antique vibe. Square diamonds, such as princess, emerald, or cushion cuts, can be both fun and quirky while maintaining elegance. Your diamond choice is the largest contribution to your custom engagement ring's overall appearance and will define the entire ring, so don't be afraid to explore!

Revamp your Setting

Perhaps you inherited your grandmother's ring, but the design is a little dated, and you're not sure your bride-to-be will appreciate the ring itself even if she loves the sentiment. Reset a family heirloom and turn it into something new again with a custom engagement ring. Using the dimensions of the existing diamond, create a stunning ring by replacing the band in a new style and adding supplementary stones, turning a plain solitaire ring into a sparkling halo setting, or simplifying an existing design by taking small exterior diamonds and turning them into a pave band, setting the diamonds into metal so the band is “paved” with tiny diamond bricks. Maintain sentimentality while creating something truly unique to you and your love story at Koerber's Fine Jewelry in the New Albany area.


Build Your Custom Engagement Ring

Create your perfect ring, from the diamond down to the details, at Koerber's Fine Jewelry. Serving the New Albany area, Koerber's Fine Jewelry provides custom engagement ring design services and consultations. Stop by our showroom to experience the best in meeting and exceeding customer expectations and start designing your custom engagement ring today.

18K White Gold Halo Oval Engagement Ring
18K White Gold Cushion Halo Engagement Ring
18K White Gold Oval Halo Engagement Ring
18K White Gold Multi Row Wide Engagement Ring
18K White Gold Cushion Halo Engagement Ring
18K White Gold Round Solitaire Engagement Ring

At Koerber's Fine Jewelry, we provide 100% “Peace of Mind ” with every purchase!

    • Shop Jewelry
    • Gemstones
    • Earrings
    • Rings
    • Necklaces
    • Bracelets
    • Permanent Jewelry
    • Engagement
    • Choose a Ring
    • Diamonds
    • Everything In Love
    • Custom Engagement Rings
    • Wedding Bands
    • Our Services
    • Financing
    • Custom Jewelry Design
    • Jewelry Repairs
    • Diamond & Gold Buying
    • Education
    • Jewelry Guides
    • Our Store
    • Our Designers
    • Upcoming Events
    • FAQS
    • Testimonials
    • Contact Us
    • Return Policy

    © 2025 Koerbers Fine Jewelry Inc. All Rights Reserved. Website designed, maintained, and hosted by Punchmark. Accessibility Statement.

    Learn how we use cookies in our Privacy Policy or manage cookie preferences.